Amplify Amplify is a place for conversation about news, thoughts and ideas
people share.
  Join David Beaudouin on Amplify!
 

Dave's Occasionally Daily Clog

I logged, I scanned, I clogged.

When Crowds Go Wild…

Social Media Group head Maggie Fox shared an interesting post today about the dark side of crowd-sourcing–namely the snarky commentary that frequently turns up on back-channel Twitter streams. Think of it as a passive-aggressive form of tossing the proverbial rotten tomato. But as Maggie points out, in the social mediaspace where everyone feels entitled to an equal voice-and all too often, to publish the first unmediated thought that pops into their heads–this chatter can veer quickly into uber-rude mobspeak.

The real issue here isn’t about those folks who think it’s cool to be cleverly snide. The larger question is whether civility (especially in professional meetups) and transparency can co-exist within this social medium. Sure, there will always be trolls and flame wars. But behaving badly in public forums, as opposed to productive candor, simply lowers the collective level of useful discourse.

Want to amp up the noise to signal with your witty snipes on Twitter? Be my guest–but here’s hoping you don’t expect much cred from your peers, or prospective clients. //

Amplifyd from socialmediagroup.com
Photo courtesy of O'Reilly Media

Photo courtesy of O’Reilly Media

danah boyd’s keynote yesterday at Web 2.0 Expo was a prime example of a mob mentality. Behind each of the speakers ran a live Twitterstream, which pulled everything tagged #w2e. In boyd’s case (she was the last speaker) the audience used it to at first criticize and then make fun of her delivery. Unfortunately, she couldn’t see the stream in order to use some of the feedback productively. All she heard was the laughter of the audience (read her perspective on it here). It was an extremely uncomfortable experience, and, frankly, it really pissed me off.

Read more at socialmediagroup.com
 

Register to comment:



9 Responses
4 Comments   5 Recommends  

  1. Eric Goldstein  Recommended this post

    1. Eric Goldstein  

      The thing i find annoying and sad is that people don’t even let themselves live in the moment because they’re too damn busy tweeting about it.


      1. Bill Sodeman  

        Should one get snarky on a public feed that’s going to live forever in a Google cache or a third-party site? It’s a good question.


        1. Chris Parandian  Recommended this post

          1. Eric Goldstein  

            That’s a good point Bill - hadn’t thought of that aspect of it.


            1. Laraluna50  Recommended this post

              1. Joe Smith  Recommended this post

                1. BL Ochman  

                  that would be a very uncomfortable, unfair spot to put a speaker in. sheesh!


                  1. Eric Weitner  Recommended this post